During the past few months, several friends have started dating someone they met online. Sure, they’ve experienced some excruciating false-starts with people they weren’t that into, but they eventually found someone with similar interests (you’re a vegetarian, dog-loving Democrat addicted to Law and Order? Me, too!).
But for Asian American women, online dating can prove more frustrating than fruitful. Sites offer a smorgasbord for men suffering from “yellow fever” and surfing for a cure. All they need do is check “Asian” as their preference and up pop thousands of profiles. But where does that leave Asian American women?
As with other forms of media, the Internet abounds with stereotypes surrounding Asian American women. Take, for example, an article a friend recently shared with me regarding a Web site aimed at men seeking to date Asian women.
According to the site, Asian women are “known for their loving and gentle nature, they are extremely loyal, supportive, and dedicated to their men.” Apparently, they also “rarely complain, are gentle and constructive with their criticism and often display a delightful sense of humor.” Who knew? Then again, ask my husband how well that description fits when it’s too hot outside, or when I want chocolate and there isn’t any in the house, or when he’s just plain pissing me the hell off.
I’m no longer in the dating scene but have had my fair share of men approaching me with expectations of some version of the Classy Asian Lady. With popular online dating sites such as Match.com and eHarmony becoming the norm, you have to wonder how the typical bar scene gets translated online.
According to an OCMetro article, a UC Irvine study found Internet dating tends to reflect racial stereotypes, with white men preferring Asian or Latino women and white women preferring African American and Latino men. Cynthia Feliciano, researcher and assistant professor of sociology and Chicano/Latino studies, says negative portrayals of African-American women and Asian men on television and in other media could contribute to those preferences. She goes on to explain that “stereotypical images of masculinity and femininity shape dating choices and continue to be perpetuated in the mass media.”
A friend who is a Korean adoptee admits she’s apprehensive about online dating after her initial experiences. Many men were disappointed to learn she grew up with Caucasian parents (not “exotic” enough). A couple of guys spent entire phone conversations enumerating the other Asians they’d dated. “I felt like I was part of a collection they had,” she later told me.
I can only imagine the similar experiences confronting Asian American women attempting to navigate the already stressful online dating scene. The thought of the annoying guy in the bar who wants to tell me all about his love for Asian culture being multiplied an infinite number of times in Cyberspace makes me cringe. At least in the bar you have the opportunity to look the guy straight in the mug and say, “Yeah right, buddy—I don’t think so. I’m no ‘Classy Asian Lady.’”
Great post! People often don't realize the double burden of being a woman of color; women have to battle both racial and gender-based stereotypes. No where is this clearer than on dating websites! It's unfortunate that these websites are just one new way to advance racial stereotypes, but it seems that the option to weed out potential dates by race often leads to men ignoring or pursuing entire races of women based on characterizations. If I was using a dating website, the very fact that a potential match had screened out African-American women or only wanted to see the profiles of Asian women would ring major alarm bells for me. How do we think media representations of masculinity/femininity and race have contributed to inclinations for certain races?
Thanks Maya! I couldn't agree more--it would ring major alarm bells for me as well. And it's so true that women of color face stereotypes based on both race and gender--passive Asian woman, hypersexual Latino woman, etc. I think media plays a major role in perpetuating stereotypes surrounding masculinity/femininity, race and gender. For example, Asian men are more often than not, still depicted as weak and emasculated while African-American men are often depicted as hyper-masculine and violent. It's so imperative there be thoughtful and active dialogue and critique surrounding such images.
Interesting somewhat related article on the correlation between race and the number of messages you receive: http://blog.okcupid.com/index.php/2009/10/05/your-race-affects-whether-people-write-you-back/
Thanks for sharing this link!! I'll definitely check it out.
"The story is a little different for the men, 59% of whom stated a racial preference. Of these, nearly half selected Asians, but fewer than 7% did for black women. Why? One theory offered by the study's lead author, Cynthia Feliciano, a sociologist at the University of California at Irvine, is that men's choices are influenced by the media's portrayal of Asian women as being hypersexual and black women as being bossy."
I'm glad SOMEONE is finally talking about this. Excellent post. Every single so called "solution" for Asian males is to have more confidence but people never consider inherent racial biases
that quote is from here by the way:
http://www.time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,1963768,00.html#ixzz0iq1ExPZd
Thanks for the feedback, Clavin!
Naaaah.. I dont believe the above mentioned comments about the asian women.. She's so shy to touch so mute to talk. Highly inferiority complexed. Visit asia and you will appreciate my comments.
Post new comment