Working at one of the community partners for Census outreach, we received a bunch of posters to publicize the Census. The poster above is one of my favorite Census 2010 posters. Overall, I think the Native Hawaiian and other Pacific Islander posters are the most beautiful, like the one above. But as I looked through the posters, I started to see an interesting pattern in representation - most of the Asian American posters do not depict people, but instead depict food or hands! For other posters targeted at Latinos, American Indians, African Americans, Arab Americans, White ethnic groups, and the general population... the images are mostly of people. You can check out all the posters at this Census website.
Here's the general breakdown for posters...
Bengali/Hindi/Korean/Urdu/Vietnamese: Tea; Hand; Lock
Chinese: Car license plate; blurred hands operating an abacus; Lock
Hmong: Food; Hand; Lock
Japanese: Origami + half a face; hand folding paper; stamp
Khmer: Tea; Khmer dancer; Lock
Laotian: Food; Lotus blossom; Lock
Native Hawaiian: Boat; Man in Native Hawaiian dress; Woman's face (above)
Pacific Islander: Boat; woman in indigenous Pacific Islander dress; Man's face
Tagalog/Filipino: Man holding up hands; Food; Lock
Thai: Food; Statue from Grand Palace in Bangkok; Lock
Personally, I really like the Native Hawaiian and Pacific Islander posters. I think they're the most artistic and evoke a sense of pride and strength. I also like the Latino targeted ones because they depict families. There don't seem to be a lot of African American targeted posters, but the one of the child, I think, is pretty cute. Interestingly, I noticed that the Puerto Rican posters are somewhat similar to the Asian American pattern of half faces, statues/buildings, and hands.
I guess I just wonder why Asian Americans are depicted mostly as objects (food and tea) and incomplete human beings, with the exception of the one Tagalog poster with a full human being. We're mostly portrayed as hands or parts of faces that are disconnected from bodies. I guess that's what bothers me most - Why are we not presented as full human beings? I'm a huge fan of food, and some of the food posters made me drool just a bit, but I don't see the relevance of food to the Census. So I ask again, why aren't Asian Americans people?
By the way, I sent mine in. Have you!? DO IT! Here's a cool map to see how your neighborhood, city, county, and state are faring in returning Census forms. Great tool for organizing your community (and peer pressure) to return forms! Interesting how Iowa and Nebraska are leaving everyone in the dust in terms of return rates.
Informative & insightful content re Census portrayals. The iconic image of a beautiful Islander girl does show pride & strength, true, but it also shows a favorite media stereotype: an Islander with leaves in her hair with a blank gaze into the horizon, probably at a romantic sunset from the beach? That image MUST be updated, don't you think? We Islanders are hard-working & highly interactive w/ our American environment; we can't help it living here trying to make it. An image of a busy PI woman behind a desk in an executive office w/ a view, dressed in professional outfit & on the phone, eyes on her computer screen OR a middle-aged PI man in front of a full class of young students, a blackboard behind him, leaning on his desk w/ a stack of calculus texts be his side--these would have been BETTER portrayals in my view. These are the "modern" CURRENT images we should be seeing of PIs, roles of the possible for all of us, not the romantic vestiages of the tourist industry that promotes the "Noble Savage" in Paradise.
Pacifican - That is such an EXCELLENT point! I commented to someone last month that the NHOPI posters could have been travel agency posters, but a colleague who is affiliated with the group that got photographed had a different take and explained that the group was very proud of the images. thanks for commenting!
Post new comment